David Friedman's
page of
links
to other comments on Lott's book or the original article.
Otis Dudley Duncan points out some false
claims by Lott about defensive gun use. In Lott's
reply
to Duncan he claims to
have conducted a survey on defensive gun use. There is no evidence
that he ever conducted such a survey as I explain
here. James
Lindgren reports his efforts to find evidence that Lott conducted a
survey here. The latest
update on this affair is here.