Lott's responses to criticisms

In chapter 7, Lott responds to many of the criticisms of his original study and in chapter 9 of the second edition he responds to criticisms of the first edition of his book. In this section, rather than just comment on the responses that I disagree with, I will also note where Lott has adequately dealt with the criticism so that readers can get an overall impression of how well Lott has responded to his critics.

In the list below, ``7.1'' refers to criticism number 1 in chapter 7.


Tim Lambert