Cognitivist and Emergent Cognition
An Alternative Perspective
A new perspective on classifying cognitive systems is presented in which a distinction is made based on how the world is represented, rather than the typical distinction between cognitivist and emergent approaches. It is argued that the typical classification in essence distinguishes between systems by their implementation, rather than by their properties. The alternative presented here instead focuses on how the system represents the world (if at all) and whether these representations are intelligible to the designer or the system itself. From this novel angle, existing systems are better classified and importantly a gap in existing cognitive systems research becomes evident. An outline of a well-founded cognitive system that fills this space is put forward, one which cognitive robotics is ideally situated to explore.
Accepted for presentation in the Special Session on Cognitive Robotics, AGI 2013 and publication in the AGI 2013 proceedings.
- Gratton, M. J. (2013). Cognitivist and Emergent Cognition — An Alternative Perspective. In P. Wang, K.-U. Kühnberger, & S. Rudolph (Eds.), Proceedings of the 6th Conference on Artificial General Intelligence, Special Session on Cognitive Robotics (pp. 192–195). Beijing, People’s Republic of China: Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg.