Organisation and Structure of Debates

Debates will be run in weeks 5 and 6.

Presentation

A concise guide to debate structure and judging can be found on the Resources page of the Debating Society of Victoria web site.

This site is a reference for those unfamiliar with formal debates. A very brief precis follows:

Introduction

The first speaker from each team should spend 2 minutes (out of the allotted 5) on a team introduction. The introduction should present the other speakers and also set the scene for the team’s argument. The A team opens.

Main body of debate

Each team member will debate the topic for no more than 5 minutes each. The A team will open and speakers from the two teams will alternate. As well as presenting arguments, the speakers should attempt to rebut the the arguments of the opposing team.

Summation

The last speaker from each team should spend 2 minutes (out of the allotted 5) on a final summation of the team’s argument. The B team has the last word.

4 person teams

Where a 3-person team is debating against a 4-person, one person from the the 3-person team will be allowed to speak twice, as a second last speaker.

During discussion each speaker will be given a warning 1 minute before the end of their allotted time. They must finish at the end of that minute.

Assessment

All marks maximum.

Additionally, there will be 1 mark for attendance at the debate sessions.

A marking guide can found here.

Tuesday 1300–1500 Quad G055 Andrew Clayphan

Tuesday 1800–2000 Quad G048 - Andrew Clayphan

Wednesday 1100–1300 Red Centre West 2035 Andrew Clayphan

Wednesday 1200–1400 Quad 2035 Peter Ho

Wednesday 1800–2000 Quad 1047 Ken Robinson